The week before Thanksgiving, I started my dishwasher and
noticed that it sounded louder than usual, so after a few minutes I opened it
to see if something was wrong and was greeted by a large puff of acrid smoke.
Considering that the unit was at least 14 years old and probably 24
(it came with the house and we’re pretty sure it was installed when the house
was originally built), it certainly didn’t owe us anything. And since the
broiler on our stove hasn’t worked in years, we figured we’d take advantage of
the Black Friday deals and replace both units at once.
Being the Queen of Research that I am, I immediately made
myself a spreadsheet of all the features I wanted (or wanted to avoid) on each
appliance, and began collecting information. I read consumer reviews on store
sites as well as independent reviewing webpages. I compared prices, I compared
availability, I asked friends for recommendations, I went to the store and
kicked some figurative tires. And after much deliberation, I am now the proud
(and satisfied!) owner of a new LG gas range and a Maytag JetClean Plus
dishwasher.
For those of you wanting specifics, the range is an LG
Electronics 5.4 cu. ft. 30 in. freestanding gas self-cleaning convection range
in stainless steel (single oven), model #LRG3095ST, from Home Depot.
In the ad and in my kitchen
It has five burners, including a “Superboil” burner which
boiled a large pot of pasta water in less than 5 minutes, and a small simmer
burner for sauces or warming. The center burner is an oval burner with a
built-in (but removable) griddle. Since we constantly kept a griddle on our old
stove, I knew I’d get lots of use out of the griddle. The main drawback to the
griddle is that it doesn’t run especially hot. The highest setting is about
equivalent to the medium setting on my old stove. It’s hot enough for pancakes
and grilled cheese, but I wouldn’t use it to sear meat like the manufacturer
suggests. The burners all light on the first click of the igniter, and I haven’t
had a problem with any of them going out accidentally when set to the lowest
setting, which was sometimes a problem with my old stove. But even if that were
a problem, there is an adjustment on each burner to tweak the flame, which is a
nice feature.
Moving on from the stovetop to the oven, let me start by
saying how spacious this oven is. Most standard ovens are 5.0 cubic feet, and
you wouldn’t think that 0.4 cubic feet would make a difference, but this oven
does feel really roomy. My old oven could handle a large turkey but this one
seems like there’s much more room for air to circulate, and I could even tuck
in an extra pan of stuffing or another side for warming. There are 7 different rack
heights, which gives a lot of flexibility for fitting in different dishes. The
oven comes with two racks, but with all this room it might be nice to have had
a third. The racks slide in and out easily. The included broiler pan is a bit
small for a large turkey, but plenty big enough for most uses. It also fits nicely
into the roomy storage drawer, still leaving space for several cookie sheets and
cooling racks. Another nice feature of the oven is that the light comes on
automatically when the door is opened but it can also be turned on manually with
the door closed so you can check on your meal (through the beautifully
oversized window) without opening the oven door. And the girly-girl in me loves
the cheery bright blue interior. The practical advantage of the blue interior –
although some might disagree – is that it will shows spills better than a
standard black interior, so you can scrub them off before they get charred on. Even
during the self-cleaning cycle, the exterior of the oven stays relatively cool,
which is a great feature for users with small children. And it pre-heats so quickly
– only about 10 minutes to get up to 350! It even shows the actual temperature
on the readout, so you know exactly how close it is to being ready.
The control panel is nicely designed and well-organized. The
digital readout is large and bright enough to read at a glance from across the room.
The oven can be set for standard bake, broil (high or low), convection bake,
convection roast (not sure what the difference between those two is), or proof (for raising bread dough). There is a thermostat
adjustment if the temperature seems to run high or low, but my oven seems to be
consistently spot on. I haven’t tried the convection modes yet, but if they
cook as evenly and consistently as the standard bake, I’ll be thrilled. And the
sound of the controls is very pleasant – instead of an annoying, shrill beep
like most stoves, the LG plays a pretty melody when it’s pre-heated, which has
the added advantage of being several seconds long so you have a better chance
of hearing it. And the entire range, including the control panel, is modern and
sleek-looking.
And now on to the dishwasher: the Maytag JetClean Plus top control
dishwasher in stainless steel with stainless steel tub and steam cleaning,
model #MDB8959SAS, from Home Depot.
In the ad and in my kitchen
We were originally looking at the next model down in this
series, but this higher-end model was on a special sale that made it even
cheaper than that model, and I’m very pleased that we ended up with this one.
The first thing I noticed about this dishwasher the first
time we used it was how incredibly quiet it is. With as little noise in the
room as a radio on at a normal level, I had to check twice to even be sure it
was running. The adjustable/removable top rack is a nice feature if you need to
wash large items like serving dishes, cutting boards, or vases, although if you
lower it slightly, even dinner plates are too tall for the lower rack. You need to be careful to pull the upper rack out evenly, as it comes off the track easily, but it's very easy to pop it back into place. The
silverware holders have removable covers, which is nice because the slots are
really too small for standard silverware. The cup racks are handy, and the cup
racks in the lower rack have holders for stemware – no more washing wineglasses
by hand, hooray! I love that feature. The first load that we ran did leave some
residue on the glassware, but since then we’re used the autosensor feature that
determines how much scrubbing a particular load needs, and everything has come
out sparkling clean since. I’ve even washed some baking dishes with
baked-on crud that I scraped and rinsed only minimally, and even they came out
perfect. The organization of the racks and tines works well for combinations of
plates, pots and pans, and serving dishes. Unlike our old dishwasher, which
always seemed to have one rack full and the other empty, this unit can accommodate
enough items in either the top or bottom rack that it seems to fill more evenly
and therefore needs to be run less often. The cycle takes more time than our
old unit (about 2-1/2 hours), but it is supposedly more energy-efficient, and
if you’re in a hurry there is a quick wash cycle that takes about an hour.
The controls are tucked on top of the unit and are partly
hidden under the counter when the door is closed, but I consider that a good
thing for avoiding curious little hands. Some reviewers complained that they
couldn’t see the buttons at all with the door closed, but our unit has just
enough clearance under the standard-height counters that I can still see them.
They are also designed so you can push Start, for example, with the door open
and as long as you close it within three seconds the cycle will start as soon
as the door is closed. There is a control lock in case the kids do manage to
find and push the buttons, but unfortunately there doesn’t seem to be a door
lock. Even when the unit is running a wash cycle, you can open the door. Handy
when you find one more spoon that needs to be thrown in, but kind of a pain if
you discover one of the kids has opened it a crack and it’s stopped mid-cycle.
The unit itself is very sleek and nice-looking, and the brushed finish cleans
off nicely with just a quick wipe with a damp rag.
The bottom line is that our kitchen now looks beautiful and
unified. Even though all three major appliances (refrigerator, dishwasher, and
stove) are from different manufacturers, they’re all stainless steel and have
similar styling that makes them look uniform and coordinated. It’s such a
pleasure cooking a meal on a stove that heats quickly, cooks evenly, and cleans
up like a dream, and then tossing the dishes into the dishwasher without having
to scrub them first, knowing they’ll still come out clean and sparkling. I love
my new kitchen!